Orgainizing Pastor – Dr. Gideon Blackburn 1824
Alexander A. Campbell 1824-27
G.W. Ashbridge 1827-30
T.M. Arnell 1830-31
James Weatherby 1831-37
J.O. Steadman 1837-45
N.A Penland 1848-50
C.F. Williams 1852-55
A.L. Kline 1856-60
B.N. Sawtelle 1861-72
H.E. Brown 1872-73
H.P. Smith 1873-77
J.G. Lane 1878-95
R.J. Beatty 1896-99
J.D. Wallace 1899-1903
Wilson F. Trump 1903-26
William Crowe IV 1926-29
William V. Gardner 1930-33
Charles F. McRae 1934-42
Adrian E. DeYoung 1942-50
Bruce H. Wideman 1950-55
James H. Patterson 1955-67
Ronald L. Siegenthaler 1969-85
George W. Mitchell 1985-87
Richard W. Markert 1988-95
Jerry R. Robbins 1996-2002
Randy E. Thompson 2002-Present